Okay, buckle up, history lovers and statue enthusiasts! I’m about to spill a secret about Lady Liberty that might just blow your mind. You know her, right? That green gal standing tall in New York Harbor, holding a torch and looking all majestic. Well, it turns out she might have a distant Italian cousin – a colossal bronze dude chilling in Arona, Italy, known affectionately as “Il Sancarlone” (the Big Charles). And no, I’m not making this up.
This isn’t some far-fetched conspiracy theory. This is a story of artistic influence, colossal ambitions, and a shared desire to create something truly awe-inspiring.
We’re talking about a 35-meter-tall statue of Saint Charles Borromeo, erected way back in the late 17th century. Think about that: a massive statue, built centuries before the Statue of Liberty, dominating the landscape of Lake Maggiore. Pretty impressive, right?
Meet Il Sancarlone – The Original Giant
Alright, let’s head to Arona, a charming town on the shores of Lake Maggiore. Here, looming over everything, stands Il Sancarlone.

This isn’t some dinky little figurine; we’re talking serious size. This bronze behemoth, dedicated to Saint Charles Borromeo, a cardinal and important figure in the Counter-Reformation, was completed in 1698. Let that sink in the 17th century!
They built this back then! Imagine the engineering challenges. No fancy cranes or computer simulations – just good old-fashioned ingenuity and a whole lot of manpower. It’s one of the tallest statues you can walk inside of.
You can climb up to the head and peek out of his eyes! Talk about a unique view. It’s truly a sight to behold, a testament to the ambition and skill of the artists and engineers of the time. This statue wasn’t just a religious symbol; it was a demonstration of power and faith, a landmark visible for miles around.
Best Sancarlone Guided Tour
Bartholdi’s Grand Tour and the Spark of Inspiration
Fast forward to the 19th century and enter Frédéric Auguste Bartholdi. This French sculptor had a big dream: to create a monumental statue symbolizing liberty for the United States. To prepare, he did what many artists did back then: he traveled.

And guess where one of his stops likely was? Italy. Now, while there’s no official record saying “Bartholdi visited Arona on Tuesday”, it’s highly probable he did. Why? Because the Sancarlone was a well-known landmark, a marvel of engineering. It would have been hard for an artist interested in large-scale sculpture to miss it.
Think about it: Bartholdi is traveling through Italy, seeing all sorts of art and architecture, and then BAM! He comes across this massive bronze figure standing tall against the Italian sky. It’s not a stretch to think this could have planted a seed in his mind. The sheer scale, the use of metal, the idea of a figure standing on a pedestal – these are all elements that would later appear in the Statue of Liberty.
Shared Traits: More Than Just Coincidence?
Let’s look at the facts. Both statues are colossal. Both are made of metal (though Liberty is copper, not bronze). Both stand on impressive bases, raising them even higher. And both depict figures with symbolic meaning.

The Sancarlone represents a religious figure, while Liberty represents, well, liberty. But the similarities in their physical presence are striking. Both are designed to be viewed from a distance, to dominate the landscape. The way they are posed, the flow of their garments (even though one is clerical robes and the other is a classical dress), there are visual echoes.
It’s crucial to understand that we’re not claiming Bartholdi simply Xeroxed the Sancarlone. That would be a disservice to his own creative genius. Instead, think of it like this: Imagine you’re a musician. You listen to all kinds of music – classical, jazz, rock, whatever. Certain melodies, rhythms, or chord progressions might stick with you, not consciously, but they seep into your musical vocabulary. Then, when you sit down to write your own song, those influences might surface in subtle ways. You’re not copying a specific song note for note, but the things you’ve absorbed have shaped your creative output.
From Italy to New York: A Legacy of Colossi

The story of the Sancarlone and the Statue of Liberty is more than just a quirky historical footnote. It’s a reminder that art and ideas don’t exist in a vacuum. They build on what came before, they borrow, they adapt, they evolve. The Sancarlone, a testament to 17th-century ingenuity, may have played a small but significant role in inspiring one of the world’s most recognizable symbols of freedom. It’s a story of how a giant in Italy might have helped give birth to a giant in America, a story that connects two very different places through a shared artistic heritage.